So, this update is a revisit of a previous scene, Kyon's inner monologue has changed, though all the spoken dialogue is the same. As for episode 1 of Yuki-chan... Funimation doesn't appear to have put up their subs as far as I'm aware? (And by extension, neither has AnimeLab, the Australian streaming service who will be simulcasting the show.) Of course, being the
translator extraordinaire I am, I am not bound by subtitles, meaning I... found another way to watch it. Without any subs. (I apologise to all legal copyright holders. I've sunk a lot of money into this franchise though and will continue to once this show has a home release!)
Overall, it was a fairly straight adaptation of the first 4 chapters of the manga. There were a few little changes though, like removing
Tsuruya-san and Mikuru's first appearance in chapter 1, by extension also removing the appearance of
Mori-san, who is depicted as a PE teacher at North High. Little of any value is lost here as Tsuruya-san's antics here are more or less the same thing she does when she turns up at the start of chapter 3, also covered by this episode, making it somewhat redundant. (Unless you're a massive Mori-san fan, in which case... Bad luck.)
The other big change from the manga is from chapter 4, where after becoming embarrassed by Kyon being too close to her while trying to plan for the Christmas party, Yuki writes about how close their faces were, before freaking out and tearing out the page, after which
she draws a doodle of them about to kiss, before tearing the page out again, the anime removes the doodle and page tearing altogether, with her merely scribbling over the writing and turning the page instead. (Which is sad, as I really liked that gag.)
Notable additions to the episode include the opening scene adding some establishing shots of the familiar scenes of Nishinomiya and North High (on that note, the manga's actual opening scene of Nagato's flashback to first meeting Kyon at the library is moved to the very end of the episode), and Asakura humming
Hare Hare Yukai as she cooks.
It seems we'll have to wait until next week to see the opening theme, the ending theme was cute, but not as good as previous Haruhi end themes like
Hare Hare Yukai,
Tomare or
Yasashii Boukyaku in my opinion.
Overall a good episode, fairly solid adaptation for the most part and wonderful to hear new material from Sugita, Chihara, Kuwatani, Gotou and Matsuoka. I'm looking forward to hearing Hirano and Ono again soon too. (Haruhi has her first speaking role in chapter 7, so probably next episode? Koizumi doesn't have his until chapter 9, so we may be waiting until episode 3 for that.)
I wonder if Funimation will bring the original cast back for the eventual dub or just do it in house in Texas? (I'd be fine losing Wendee Lee's Haruhi, but I really like the rest of the dub cast.)
( Read more... )